I was walking in the old city of Jerusalem today when a yeshivish guy, around 30 years old, asked me for some monetary help for Shabbat.
I said no.
The thing is, I used to always give to anyone who asked. Not just Jews. When I lived in NY, unless it was shabbat or I had no change on me, I gave something to any panhandler who wasn't an obvious junkie. Not much, just a dime or a quarter, or in Israel, a shekel. But something.
However, I moved away from New York a few years ago. A few states away. And ever since I've lived in places with very few panhandlers, so I'm out of practice.
So today was my first experience for quite a while. And when I was approached by a healthy looking guy without any apparent disabilities, I immediately thought "kollel guy".
My second thought was "why should I help to perpetuate a system I disagree with? I see nothing noble in learning Torah full time if it means having to turn to tzedaka for your family to buy food for shabbat."
So I said no. He walked on and I immediately felt guilty. After all, maybe he's not a kollel guy. Maybe he's a poor guy who can't find a job? But based on his look, my initial instinct was probably correct. But even if he was a kollel guy, in the old days I would never have said no to someone asking for help for shabbat.
Maybe I read too many blogs complaining about the kollel system...
So what do you think? Was I being smart or just stingy?
Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry